TOP TEN (OR FOURTEEN) INDICATORS OF ILLEGAL MOTIVE - A PLAINTIFF'S PERSPECTIVE
Submitted by:
James S. Weliky
Messing, Rudavsky & Weliky, P.C.
50 Congress Street, Suite 1000
Boston, MA 02109
(617) 742-0004
(c) 2006 James S. Weliky
Sudden threats of termination and/or termination for performance problems where no prior communications to the employee about those problems
Absence of contemporaneous documentation of performance problems
Post hoc attempts to “document” performance problems
Failure to follow established disciplinary policies
Failure to follow established evaluation procedures
Inconsistent application of established practices or policies
Contradictory, embellished or inconsistent statements of reasons for adverse actions
In reductions-in-force, retention of younger, less experienced co-workers for no defensible reason
In reductions-in-force, sudden transfers of younger, less experienced co-workers shortly before announcement of layoffs
One or two person “reduction-in-force”
Sudden intensive scrutiny where none previously and/or where no prior indication of work difficulties
Punishing the victim in harassment cases, e.g. putting the accuser on leave rather than the accused, transferring the accuser out of the accused's department
Manipulation of the promotion or hiring process so that only desired candidates “qualify”
Demanding detailed health records to document disability and providing them to supervisor and/or supervisor asking employee if she/he has a disability
|